Catch a show and take the late train back from Pawling, NY
via Metro North to/from New York City (and stops along the Harlem Line)
The last train leaves Pawling Train Station towards Grand Central Station anywhere from 10:52PM - 11:54 PM depending on the day of the week.
ALWAYS VERIFY YOUR TRAIN TIMES WITH METRO NORTH.
From the train, it is a short taxi ride to Daryls House - call your cab in advance.
Pawling Train Station Taxi - (845) 855-9800 cost~$7+tip
Pawling Taxi - (845) 855-8585 cost~$7+tip